What the Comments Reveal (Beyond Views & Likes)
2.1M views and 38K likes — in “17 Signs of KIDNEY DISEASE You Can See: Doctor Explains” on Violin MD, as of 2025-08-28, with 1,554 total comments. From a 500-comment sample, we analyze what engaged viewers are truly saying.
Sentiment Snapshot
The audience leaned positive overall, with many showing appreciation and curiosity, while a notable share expressed concerns or frustrations.
Emotional Pulse: Grateful Leads the Way
Viewers were most thankful for the clarity and depth of information, while many were curious about symptoms and tests. Some expressed frustration or concern over missed diagnoses and medical inattention.
Comment Breakdown: Personal Stories and Compliments Dominate
The conversation blends personal health stories, direct questions, and high praise, with lighter engagement and constructive feedback also present.
Siobhan Deshauer’s Engagement in the Comments
Roughly 1 in 4 comments received a heart, showing strong acknowledgment of the community. Replies were rare, but overall interaction signals attentiveness.
Burning Questions
Viewers want clear guidance on early kidney disease detection: foamy urine, which first labs to check, and what healthy ranges for eGFR and A1c look like. They also ask whether proteinuria can improve, how CKD causes anemia, and whether stage 3a is serious. Others worry about hydration, the impact of dehydration, water intake during night shifts, and the effects of electrolyte drinks.
Medication safety sparked recurring concerns, with questions about metformin and newer agents like Farxiga. Viewers also wanted clarity on diet and prevention—whether early disease can be reversed with food and exercise, what role phosphorus/potassium additives play, and how lifestyle choices affect outcomes. Beyond kidneys, some drifted into related conditions, showing broad trust in the creator’s medical explanations.
Feedback and Critiques
Many praised the video’s thoroughness and practical value, highlighting warnings about NSAID overuse and the emphasis on subtle CKD signs. Several suggested doctors should pay closer attention to symptoms like cramps and recommended annual checkups for prevention. Some requested more actionable guidance: specific diets, lifestyle steps, and prevention strategies, especially beyond “watch and wait.”
A minority raised accuracy and tone critiques—asking for better analogies, pronunciation refinements, and a more serious delivery style for CKD symptoms. Others flagged systemic issues such as dismissive care, high costs, and insurance barriers, underscoring frustration with the broader healthcare system. Requests also surfaced for expanded context around related symptoms, such as nocturia, gout, autoimmune issues, and mineral imbalances.
High Praise
Viewers described Dr. Deshauer as an outstanding educator, with many calling the video the best online resource they’d found on kidney health. Praise centered on her clear explanations, evidence-based confidence, and effective use of visuals that made complex physiology accessible. Health professionals echoed this, saying they plan to share the video with patients as a trusted learning tool.
Commenters also admired the blend of compassion and thoroughness, noting that the video filled gaps left by rushed clinical visits. From retired pathologists to nephrology educators, feedback emphasized its practical, actionable value and praised the channel for consistently delivering clarity and empowerment.
Opportunities for Future Content
- The kidney-safe diet by stage: practical 7-day meal plans, grocery lists, hydration guidance, and evidence-based supplements.
- Catch it early: foamy urine, blood, and other silent clues decoded + first labs to order, how often to test, and referral triggers.
- Can CKD be reversed? What’s reversible vs not, with a step-by-step plan to slow decline and avoid pitfalls.
- Fatigue, anemia, cramps, and itchy skin: the kidney–bone–blood connection explained with labs and treatments that help.
- Living with one kidney or after transplant: what GFR swings are normal, when to seek urgent care, and daily protection strategies.
- When doctors don’t listen: a self-advocacy roadmap with tracking tools, referral triggers, and escalation strategies.
Wrapping Up
This video strikes a balance between depth and accessibility, earning gratitude and trust from viewers. While many asked for more concrete diet and prevention guidance, the strong engagement and high praise show that clear, compassionate explanations resonate deeply. Shono AI highlights these signals to help amplify what matters most to the audience.
About This Analysis
Methodology & Limits
We compared a 500-comment sample against the total 1,554. Spam and duplicates were removed. Comments were AI-classified by sentiment, emotion, and type, then aggregated into insights.
Engagement rates reflect the sampled set only. Snapshot as of 2025-08-28; values may shift as new comments arrive.
