What the Comments Reveal (Beyond Views & Likes)
2.1M views and 137K likes on “how i fixed my attention span” from Answer in Progress as of 2025-09-18, with 4,109 total comments and a 1,000 comment sample analyzed, reveal what engaged viewers really think.
Sentiment Snapshot
Most viewers responded positively, showing enthusiasm for both the experiment and practical advice.
Emotional Pulse: Curious Leads the Way
Viewers were mainly curious about replicating the experiment, with notable frustration about missing technical details and amusement at the creative storytelling. Gratitude and reflection show appreciation for both methods and lessons learned.
Comment Breakdown: Personal stories and Compliments Dominate
The mix includes personal experiences, direct praise, casual reactions, unanswered questions, and constructive complaints.
Answer in Progress’s Engagement in the Comments
No replies or reactions were made, meaning ~1 in ∞ comments received engagement.
Burning Questions
Viewers are eager for replicability. They asked for the exact EEG headset, scripts to export iOS Screen Time data, analysis workflows, and whether the Notion template is available. Many also pressed for app names that enabled grayscale icons and text labels, and requested updates on whether meditation benefits lasted months later.
Broader concerns surfaced around ADHD, anxiety management, music aids, menstrual cycle tracking, and whether sponsorships influenced tool recommendations. Overall, the demand is for a methods bundle plus sustained outcome reporting.
Feedback and Critiques
Many praised the meditation framework as strengthening prefrontal control, comparing it to rest days in training. Tactics like do-not-disturb, note offloading, timeboxing, and sleep prioritization felt practical. Some reported success with yoga and retreats, while skeptics noted they were newly open to meditation.
Critiques focused on missing context: viewers wanted deeper dopamine explanations, ADHD and depression acknowledgment, and clearer links to tools and metrics. Some challenged cultural claims about meditation’s origins and flagged minor editing distractions. Requests for a follow-up on exercise, diet, and social connections were common.
High Praise
Viewers applauded the evidence-based approach, saying the data-driven tips stood apart from typical advice. The personal journey and transparency about struggles made the content relatable and inspiring, with many calling it life-changing.
Production quality was also widely admired, from inventive cinematography to respectful sponsorship disclosures. Many new viewers subscribed immediately, impressed by the blend of rigor and engaging storytelling.
Opportunities for Future Content
- Your phone vs your brain: a dopamine-deep-dive and protocol to rebuild attention
- ADHD or just distracted? Science-backed self-check and ADHD-friendly focus plan
- Replicate my attention experiment: toolkit and step-by-step guide
- Does it last? A 60–90 day follow-up with real metrics
- Meditation for skeptics: micro-practices that feel like rest
- Make your phone boring: distraction-proofing makeover
Wrapping Up
The video’s strength lies in its rigorous yet relatable approach, blending personal experimentation with clear data. Opportunities remain to provide more technical resources, address broader wellbeing factors, and interact directly with viewers. Shono AI helps spotlight these signals so creators can turn them into meaningful connections.
About This Analysis
Methodology & Limits
The analysis is based on 1,000 sampled comments out of 4,109. Spam and duplicates were removed before AI classification and aggregation.
Engagement rates reflect the sampled set only. Snapshot as of 2025-09-18. Values may shift as new comments arrive.
