What the Comments Reveal (Beyond Views & Likes)
1.4M views and 26K likes on “DOES THE KETO DIET KILL? Doctor Reviews Low Carb Diets and Mortality” from Violin MD as of 2025-09-30. With 10,729 total comments and a 1,000-comment sample analyzed, we look beyond surface metrics to see what engaged viewers are really saying.
Sentiment Snapshot
The discussion is polarized, with negative sentiment (28.63%) unusually high compared to other nutrition videos, signaling frustration and criticism mixed with curiosity.
Emotional Pulse: Curiosity Leads the Way
Viewers are intensely curious yet divided—many push for clarity while others voice frustration or concern, signaling a demand for rigorous explanations and practical dietary guidance.
Comment Breakdown: Personal Stories and Feedback Dominate
The mix skews toward personal experiences and feedback, with notable complaints and critical takes adding intensity to the discussion.
Siobhan Deshauer’s Engagement in the Comments
Interaction was minimal—about 1 in 111 comments received a reply or heart, suggesting room to build stronger community connection by acknowledging more voices.
Burning Questions
Viewers demand rigorous transparency: definitions of “low-carb,” inclusion of refined carbs, subgroup outcomes, cause-of-death detail, and funding disclosures. They probe study design, confounders, and generalizability—from Inuit diets to genetic variability.
On the practical side, many want guidance on plant-based keto options, saturated fat risks, and diabetes management. Questions extend to dementia, seafood, refeeding, and even the creator’s personal stance and diet updates.
Feedback and Critiques
Many emphasized moderation, personalization, and food quality, highlighting Mediterranean, plant-forward, and low-glycemic approaches. Whole foods and fiber-rich carbs were praised, while processed meats and refined sugars drew critique.
Sharp critiques targeted study design: broad “low-carb” cutoffs, reliance on self-reports, and lack of confounder control. Viewers want clarity on saturated fat, fiber, and biomarkers, pushing for updated, rigorous trials that differentiate keto from general low-carb diets.
High Praise
Though concise, praise highlighted standout quality. Viewers noted the video was clear, well-structured, and professional—delivering value that felt accessible and worthwhile.
This brevity signals trust: when viewers thank you without elaboration, it often means the delivery felt efficient, polished, and aligned with their needs.
Opportunities for Future Content
- Keto vs Low-Carb vs Carnivore: strict definitions, biomarkers, and outcomes.
- How to trust nutrition studies: funding, design, and data quality.
- Food quality, fat type, and fiber on low-carb diets.
- Intermittent fasting and autophagy—realistic timelines and risks.
- Keto for type 2 diabetes and fatty liver: safe, step-by-step protocol.
- A sustainable “clean keto” starter plan with meal templates and troubleshooting.
Wrapping Up
This video sparked polarized reactions—viewers shared stories, pressed for research rigor, and voiced concerns about methodology. By adding clarity on definitions and offering practical guidance, Siobhan can build even more trust. Shono AI helps surface these audience signals, making it easier to fine-tune future content with precision.
About This Analysis
Methodology & Limits
Sample size vs total comments; with duplicates and spam removed. AI classified comments by sentiment, emotion, and type, then aggregated the results.
Engagement rates reflect the sampled set only. Snapshot as of 2025-09-30; values may shift as new comments arrive.
