What the Comments Reveal (Beyond Views & Likes)
3.7M views and 103K likes on “Anti-Aging Expert: Missing This Vitamin Is As Bad As Smoking! The Truth About Creatine!” from The Diary Of A CEO. As of 2025-09-19 the video had 6,175 total comments, with 1,000 sampled here. Beyond raw numbers, we analyze engaged viewers.
Sentiment Snapshot
Overall sentiment leaned positive, though a sizable group raised concerns.
Emotional Pulse: Curious Leads the Way
Curiosity drove much of the conversation, with gratitude and admiration also high. Frustration and concern signaled demand for clarity and reassurance.
Comment Breakdown: Compliment and Question Dominate
Viewers mixed praise, questions, and personal stories with constructive feedback and occasional complaints.
Steven Bartlett’s Engagement in the Comments
Only about 1 in 140 comments received a reply or heart, suggesting room for deeper creator interaction.
Burning Questions
Viewers want precise, science-backed answers about creatine, magnesium, vitamin D, and omega-3. They asked about dosing, timing with fasting, capsule counts, brand quality, and side effects across different populations. Safety for teens, shift workers, and those with medical conditions was a recurring theme.
Beyond supplements, they requested links to studies, summaries of evidence, and future guest suggestions. Broader curiosities spanned fasting risks, Blue Zone diets, and specialized topics like adrenal adenomas, chronic fatigue, and IVF.
Feedback and Critiques
Many praised the episode’s density of clear, practical science. It motivated exercise, dietary shifts, and supplement changes while applauding production details like chaptering.
Critiques called for nuance on low-carb diets, precision on supplement dosing, and attention to controversies. Some wanted concise takeaways, multilingual options, and fact-checking to avoid bias.
High Praise
Viewers described the conversation as a master class, lauding Dr Rhonda Patrick’s expertise and communication. They valued evidence-based insights that were easy to follow and highly actionable.
Many reported lifestyle changes inspired directly by the episode, from gym intensity to supplement regimens, and credited the host’s interviewing for making complex science accessible and engaging.
Opportunities for Future Content
- The Creatine Blueprint: evidence, dosing, timing, and safety for real life
- Magnesium, decoded: which type for which issue, how much, and when
- Omega-3 without the confusion: fish vs algae vs plant sources, rancidity, and dose that actually moves the needle
- Keto, carbs, and fasting: who thrives, who should not, and how to personalize
- The everyday exposure audit: simple swaps that cut plastics, liners, and contaminants
- Supplement shopping school: how to pick brands, read labels, and avoid junk
Wrapping Up
This episode earned strong trust for its clarity and science while also surfacing areas for sharper guidance. Personalization and balance will strengthen future conversations, and Shono AI amplifies these audience signals to guide what comes next.
About This Analysis
Methodology & Limits
The analysis covers 1,000 sampled comments out of 6,175. Duplicates and spam were removed, and AI classification was used for sentiment, emotions, and comment type aggregation.
Engagement rates reflect the sampled set only. Snapshot as of 2025-09-19; values may shift as new comments arrive.
