What Actually Breaks Your Fast? Coffee, Sweeteners, Supplements & Thresholds
Voice of the Audience
“Does coffee with stevia stop autophagy?”
— YouTube comment
“Is lemon water okay in the morning, or does it break my fast?”
— YouTube comment
“How many grams of carbs or protein actually break fasting and autophagy—3, 5, 10?”
— YouTube comment
Developed from thousands of YouTube comments and expert insights from Andrew Huberman, Dr. Eric Berg, Dr. Jason Fung, Dr. Sten Ekberg, and Dr. Alan Goldhamer. For deeper context and full rankings of top fasting videos, see our research-backed fasting guide.
The Concern
Confusion reigns: does lemon water, coffee with cream, stevia, MCT oil, or supplements break a fast? Viewers want hard thresholds for carbs, protein, or fat that disrupt fasting goals like weight loss, autophagy, or gut rest.
The Tip
What breaks a fast depends on your goal. For strict autophagy or gut rest: zero calories (plain water, black coffee, unsweetened tea). For metabolic health/weight loss: small amounts of fat (MCT oil, cream) may not spike glucose but still add calories. When in doubt—test blood glucose/ketones or assume it breaks your fast.
Creators Addressed
- Dr. Eric Berg — discusses coffee with cream/collagen; notes citrus may stop autophagy but black coffee is safe.
- Andrew Huberman — mentions lemon/lime water, MCT oil as possibly safe metabolically; but calorie content matters for autophagy.
- Dr. Jason Fung — accepts coffee with cream for some protocols but sugar breaks fasting.
- Dr. Sten Ekberg — warns sweeteners (even stevia) can spike insulin for some; precise carb/protein grams matter.
- Dr. Alan Goldhamer — defines true fasting as only water, nothing else.
Related Raw Comments
- “Does coffee with collagen and cream ruin my fast?”
- “Is lemon/lime water safe or does it kick me out of autophagy?”
- “If stevia spikes glucose, is black coffee the only safe option?”
Quick Summary (Do This Tonight)
For strict fasting: stick to plain water, black coffee, or unsweetened tea. Anything with calories—carbs, protein, or significant fat—will break the fast. Sweeteners are controversial; safest to avoid if unsure.
How to Do It
- Strict autophagy goal: only plain water, black coffee, or plain tea.
- Metabolic/weight loss goal: small amounts of fat may be tolerated, but carbs/protein break the fast.
- Sweeteners: even zero-calorie ones may spike insulin for some; test or avoid.
- Supplements: take during eating window unless calorie-free and approved.
- Self-test: use a glucometer/ketone strips if unsure how your body reacts.
Common Mistakes & Fixes
- Adding milk/cream to coffee — breaks strict fast. Fix: stick to black.
- Trusting “zero calorie” sweeteners — some spike insulin. Fix: test or avoid.
- Using green powders or vitamins — often have calories. Fix: take with meals.
Quick Answers (FAQ)
Does coffee break a fast?
Black coffee, no additives, is safe. Anything added with calories breaks it.
Does lemon water break fasting?
Minimal sugar (≈1 g) is often negligible metabolically but plain water is safest for autophagy.
Does MCT oil break fasting?
It adds calories (~130 per tbsp). Doesn’t spike glucose but not a true fast.
Do sweeteners break fasting?
They may for some. Stevia is debated. If strict, avoid all sweeteners.
Do supplements break fasting?
Most multivitamins contain calories/fillers. Best taken with meals unless directed otherwise.
Bottom Line
“What breaks a fast?” isn’t one answer—it depends on your fasting goal. For purity: only water. For metabolic goals: small allowances may be okay. Define your goal, then choose your rules.
Note: This guide is informational, not medical advice. Follow your clinician’s guidance if you’re on medication or long fasts.
Looking for the Best Fasting Video?
We compared 5 top fasting videos (26M+ views, 36k+ comments analyzed) to see what really works.
