What the Comments Reveal (Beyond Views & Likes)
2.2M views and 53K likes on “What Does Creatine Do? | Nutritionist Explains... | Myprotein” from Myprotein as of 2025-09-23. With 1,370 total comments and 768 analyzed here, we go beyond surface metrics to see how engaged viewers really responded.
Sentiment Snapshot
Overall, sentiment skews positive, with curiosity and praise outweighing complaints, though a notable portion voiced concerns.
Emotional Pulse: Curiosity Leads the Way
Viewers were most curious, often seeking clarity on creatine’s effects, with amusement and gratitude present but tempered by pockets of concern and frustration.
Comment Breakdown: Questions and Engagement Dominate
A mix of questions, quick engagements, and compliments made up most responses, with a healthy share of personal stories and some complaints.
Myprotein’s Engagement in the Comments
Roughly 1 in 17 comments received a creator interaction, signaling room for more visible engagement to build trust.
Burning Questions
Viewers wanted clarity on whether creatine causes bloating, puffiness, or fat gain, and how it affects fat loss phases. Safety dominated concerns, from kidney and liver health to hair loss, hydration, and use alongside conditions like diabetes or high blood pressure. Dosing and timing questions were constant—loading vs. daily intake, rest days, fasting, and combining with whey or pre-workout.
A second cluster centered on access and expectations: sourcing vegan creatine, body fat thresholds for starting, long-term effects, and tolerance. Curiosity spilled into fringe areas like cognitive benefits for exams and dementia. Overall, the audience sought tailored, practical, evidence-based guidance for different ages, genders, and training styles.
Feedback and Critiques
Viewers appreciated the clear, science-based framing, saying the chemistry explanation finally made creatine click. Practical dosing advice was valued, and many felt normalized by the reminder that the body produces creatine naturally.
Requests for more depth centered on risks, who should avoid creatine, and vegan sourcing. Some corrected definitions or flagged that weight gain is often water, not muscle. Production notes urged trimming intros, stabilizing visuals, and acknowledging variability in responses. A few worried about impartiality due to brand ties.
High Praise
Viewers repeatedly called this the best explanation they had seen, praising its clarity, balance of detail and accessibility, and evidence-based delivery. The absence of hype boosted trust, and many valued the affordability of long-term dosing.
Appreciation often turned personal—playful adoption jokes, affectionate remarks, and family pride—reflecting the strong connection between the creator and the community.
Opportunities for Future Content
- Will creatine make me look puffy or fat? The real story on water weight, bloat, and staying lean—plus practical fixes.
- Creatine side effects, myths, and safety: hair loss, kidney/liver health, blood pressure, alcohol, and what research shows.
- The creatine protocol that actually works: loading vs. no-load, dosing, timing, hydration, fasting, and stacking with whey or pre-workout.
- Creatine for every age and gender: guidance for teens, women, and 40+ lifters—when to start, how much, and parental considerations.
- Vegan creatine explained and how to buy right: purity, forms, cost-effective picks, and what to avoid.
- Creatine beyond powerlifting: HIIT, MMA, endurance, and bodyweight training—when it helps, when it doesn’t, and tailoring intake.
Wrapping Up
This video delivered a strong science-first primer on creatine, earning trust and praise. The biggest opportunities lie in addressing safety, myths, and practical tailoring. By leaning into specific viewer concerns and questions, Shono AI helps surface what matters most—turning comment signals into a roadmap for content that connects.
About This Analysis
Methodology & Limits
The analysis compares a 768-comment sample against the total, with duplicates and spam removed. AI classified comments by sentiment, emotion, and type, then aggregated the results.
Engagement rates reflect the sampled set only. Snapshot as of 2025-09-23; values may shift as new comments arrive.
