What the Comments Reveal (Beyond Views & Likes)
7.3M views and 121K likes on “What Happens To Your Body After Taking Creatine For 30 Days?” by Jeremy Ethier. As of 2025-09-19, the video has 5521 total comments, with 1000 sampled here. Beyond the numbers, we analyze how engaged viewers really felt and what they still want to know.
Sentiment Snapshot
Audience sentiment is split, with positivity and neutrality balanced by a high share of concerns.
Emotional Pulse: Curiosity Leads the Way
Viewers show high curiosity and concern, signaling both eagerness to learn and anxiety about side effects.
Comment Breakdown: Personal Stories and Questions Dominate
Most comments are stories and questions, showing strong interest in real experiences and clear guidance.
Jeremy Ethier’s Engagement in the Comments
No replies or reactions were recorded. This leaves valuable viewer questions unanswered.
Burning Questions
Viewers ask whether weight spikes during loading are normal, how much water to drink, and if dosing should be based on body size. They also want clarity on powder versus pills, HCL versus monohydrate, and whether rest day dosing is necessary.
Safety questions span teens to older adults, focusing on blood pressure, bone density, hair loss, and mental health. Many wonder about long-term use, appetite changes, and whether creatine helps yoga, running, or lighter training styles.
Feedback and Critiques
Many valued the explanations on water retention and recovery, noting it helped them connect visible changes to real benefits. Some suggested showing body weight dosing instead of flat numbers and addressing confusion around loading phases.
Viewers debated monohydrate versus HCL, reported side effects like headaches and nausea, and asked for more precise product recommendations. Presentation feedback focused on clarity, unit conversions, and covering caffeine or stacking supplements.
High Praise
Viewers consistently praised the clarity and structure of explanations, highlighting the unbiased, no-sales tone. Many found the content both approachable and trustworthy, especially compared to hype-driven fitness content.
Several noted that the lack of brand tie-ins made the advice feel transparent. Even trainers commented that the video addressed real client questions that are often hard to answer.
Opportunities for Future Content
- The Creatine Water & Weight Blueprint
- Personalizing Your Creatine Dose
- Who should take creatine and who should be cautious
- Cutting, recomp, and being overweight on creatine
- Troubleshooting why creatine is not working
- Beyond muscle: creatine for endurance, joints, and brain health
Viewer Voices
Here are a few unfiltered comments from the community:
i gained 5 pounds in the first week and thought something was wrong thanks for clearing it up
is it safe for a 16 year old to take creatine ive been lifting for 2 years but not sure if it will stunt growth
creatine monohydrate makes me feel bloated should i switch to hcl or just lower the dose
this is the first video that explained why i should still take it on rest days really helpful
Wrapping Up
Viewers clearly appreciate the clarity and transparency of the content but crave more direct answers to their practical questions. Personalization and hydration guidance are key areas to strengthen. With Shono AI surfacing these signals, creators can respond with precision and deepen trust with their audience.
About This Analysis
Methodology & Limits
The analysis covers 1,000 sampled comments out of 5,521. Duplicates and spam were removed, and AI classification was used for sentiment, emotions, and comment type aggregation.
Engagement rates reflect the sampled set only. Snapshot as of 2025-09-19; values may shift as new comments arrive.
